The death of the 4-4-2?

Dead and gone?

As I watched Tottenham get the run around by some Young Boys last night I couldn’t help but be reminded of England’s nightmarish world cup campaign.

Not because of the white kit on show and not because of a defence woefully short of pace, but because it was the last time I saw a team play 4-4-2 against a foreign opposition. Coincidentally it was also the last time I saw a team that exposed in midfield and on the counter attack.

Top level football has undoubtedly changed over the last few years. So much so that I can’t think of the last time I saw two top class teams line up against each other in a 4-4-2 formation, particularly in a big game. Players are better on the ball nowadays and possession is key. Ever since Claude Makelele took it upon himself to master and patent the ‘Makelele position’ no top team is without one, in some cases two, and in the odd case even three.

The once thankless task of breaking up play and sitting in front of the back four is now the key position. It has long been acknowledged that in ‘The Championship’ you are only as good as your strikers, well now I think it’s fair to say that in Europe you are only as good as you’re holding midfield players. The chain begun a while back; one less striker stood upfront means more players playing in the ‘hole’ in-between a defence and attack, these players that operate here are the best in the world and need looking after. Somewhere along this dangerous chain of events we have ended up with a player like Yaya Toure being valued at twenty eight million pounds and earning two hundred and twenty thousand pound a week. If that does not emphasise how important these players are then nothing will.

It would not surprise me if over the coming seasons children in the school yards start filling their Merlin sticker collections with holding midfielders as they become bigger stars. Imagine that in our day? “I’ll give you two Dennis Bergkamp’s for one David Batty?”. It is hard to see how this can possibly be good for football but never the less it is happening.

For Tottenham and England to succeed at the highest level they need a change of tactics. England showed signs of it in their recent friendly against Hungary, deploying an out of sorts Wayne Rooney alone up front with runners playing off him. Spurs will need to do the same if they are to have any hope in the Champions League. They certainly have the players to play a ‘modern formation’ but whether Harry will have to upset one or two of his strikers in order to succeed. Jermaine Defoe will certainly be a casualty for both England and Spurs if this trend continues.

There is no doubt it makes a game of football less of a spectacle but the Irony is the bigger the ‘Beautiful’ game gets the more business orientated it becomes consequently the bigger a defeat becomes.

Goodbye four-four-two, you had your moments but times change, people change. It’s me not you and all that…


2 Comments on “The death of the 4-4-2?

    • I can recall Andy Gray bemoaning the sudden love for holding midfielders during the Spurs vs Man City match on Saturday.

      To a degree it ruined the World Cup as more teams were prepared to defend rather than attack. Something is going wrong with football when there are more defensive midfielders on a pitch than strikers.

      Got to agree that it’s something England should adopt at International level though. It would mask our poor inability to retain possession.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: