The most overrated player in world football?

Javier Mascherano: The most overrated player in world football?

Although every football fan in the world recognises the genius of the likes of Lionel Messi, Xavi, Arjen Robben and Andres Iniesta, there are always one or two heavily lauded players who split opinion. For me, one of those players is Javier Mascherano.

I have seen Mascherano play countless times for both Liverpool and Argentina (though admittedly not at West Ham, where he wasn’t deemed good enough by Alans Pardew and Curbishley to displace Hayden Mullins from the starting eleven) and have yet to see the Argentine justify all the hyberbole that surrounds his performances in his preferred holding role.

Don’t get me wrong, Mascherano is by no means a bad player – he can pass the ball competently, tackle (reasonably) effectively and has a decent engine. But is he really worthy of all the exalted praise that comes his way? During his short stint as national coach Diego Maradona famously said that Argentina was a team of “Mascherano and 10 others”, while his old Liverpool boss Rafa Benitez was equally effusive in his praise, describing him as a ‘monster of a player’.

How Mascherano could be on the teamsheet before the world’s best player Lionel Messi is a debate for another day, but what was equally puzzling was Maradona’s decision to play the 26-year-old in the defensive midfield role at the expense of Esteban Cambiasso, a far more effective and experienced campaigner. A look at their respective trophy cabinets would validate that argument, with Cambiasso playing a pivotal role in Inter Milan’s treble-winning campaign last year while Mascherano has yet to lay his hands on a single trophy in his three years on Merseyside. The amount of needless fouls Mascherano concedes with reckless and ill-timed challenges also makes him a less than aesthetically-pleasing player to watch for the neutral supporter.

Cambiasso also offers more of a threat going forward, chipping in with four goals last season, including a vital strike against Chelsea in the Champions League knockout stages. Mascherano has a miserable three goals to his name in three seasons at Anfield, and rarerly breaks forward to support Liverpool or indeed Argentine attacks, preferring to sit deep and take the ball from the nearest centre-half before passing it sideways, much like ‘The Crab’ Ray Wilkins did in his pomp.

Comparisons with Claude Makelele, arguably the most effective player in that defensive holding role in the modern era, are similarly wide of the mark. Again, one glance at Makelele’s record at Real Madrid and Chelsea will tell you he has been much more effective in that role than Argentina’s captain. Indeed, his sale to the West Londoners at the height of the Galactico era coincided with Madrid’s trophyless run and Chelsea’s renaissance as a major force in English football. Zinedine Zidane summed up the feeling among the Madrid players when he said of his compatriots departure: “Why put another layer of gold paint (David Beckham) on the Bentley when you are losing the entire engine?”

Of course, you could argue, and with good reason, that Makelele and Cambiasso have played in better sides than Mascherano. That may be true, but both players have become the heartbeat of their respective club teams, driving them forward and creating opportunities for their team-mates. Mascherano, on the other hand, seems to operate in such a small area of the field that he is never likely to take up that mantle.

Perhaps the game that exposed Mascherano’s limitations more than any other was Argentina’s 4-0 thrashing by Germany in this summer’s World Cup. In this case, you couldn’t say that Mascherano was lining up in the less talented side. In the opposing team, Bastian Schweinsteiger, a relative novice in the  deep-lying role, taught the Argentine a brutal lesson on how to break up attacks, protect your defence and distribute the ball before joining in with a swift counter attack.

Mascherano admittedly had a huge job on his hands trying to provide protection for a back four that featured the hapless Martin Demechelis and Nicolas Otamendi, but by all accounts he put in a wretched performance in Cape Town as Argentina’s World Cup dreams imploded in embarassing fashion. And it’s not like he was taken by surprise by  the Germans set-up – they had played in exactly the same way in their 4-1 thrashing of England in the previous round. As captain, it was his responsibility to bring some order to the chaos around him, organise his team-mates on the pitch and keep their heads up when they went a goal behind early on.

In the event, Schweinsteiger bossed the midfield with such ease it is surprising that Mascherano’s stock remains so high this summer. Perhaps £30m from Inter Milan for his services would be the best bit of business  Liverpool could do this summer.


8 Comments on “The most overrated player in world football?

  1. Couldnt agree more. I was pretty much saying the same last night whilst watching Liverpool in the Europa cup qualifier. (that Liverpool kit is a shocker!)

    I think he was mainly used for the champions league, now they’re not in it, they should sell him. He’s clearly not motivated.

    If they get a bid anywhere in the region of £20 mill, they should sell. Poormans David Batty without the Yorkshire grit and drive.

  2. The obvious answer would be no, he isn’t the most over-rated player in world football. Having watched most of Liverpool’s matches in the time he’s been there i’d say you cant under-estimate the momentum he can give the team. It is very noticable how other players feed off his drive and determination. However, that’s not to say there aren’t other players out there who can do the same job.

    Argentina captain, coveted by the current european champions with barcelona amongst his long term admirers. Obviously not everyone’s cup of tea but clearly a player of some worth…

    Not sure about comparisons with other players in his postion that have been more successful? Dodgy ground – is tiago a better player/more effective player than gerrard because of the trophies he won at Chelsea?

  3. Overrated no? Effective but limited yes?

    Mascherano is arguably one of the best defensive midfielders in world football. He is not in a team to score goals or provide countless assists. Mascherano’s sole role is to protect the defence and provide a platform for his team mates to attack.

    In my honest opinion there are very, very few players who can do that better than Mascherano.

  4. I don’t know if Mascherano is over-rated. I think he does a job and does it fairly well.

    It is all well and good saying that he covers the defence but he didn’t do that too often for Liverpool and for Argentina was scarily out of position on a number of occassions. Sure, he is but one man. But still.

    For me the most over-rated soon to be internationals are in the England Squad right now. Jack Whiltshire and Gibbs. Hardly got 25 appearances between them but the hope for the future. Underserved. Worrying.

  5. @ Francis Benali
    Fair point about Mascherano’s heart and determination rubbing off on his team mates – that’s one thing I can’t take away from him. However, whenever I watch him I just don’t think his passing range, tackling (he concedes far too many fouls) or organisation skills are up to much, especially when you compare him to others in his position, such as Schweinsteiger or YaYa Toure. He has a good engine, of that there is no doubt, and he is by no means a bad player, I just don’t think Liverpool will miss him as much as some commentators are making out. Someone like Christian Poulsen could do his job just as effectively and give Hodgson another £20m to spend on attacker to lead the line when Torres is injured (i.e for 25+ games a season!)

  6. It do not say anything about the quality of the player, quality defines its rating.
    Macherano is best in his position and role, a positionaly safegaurding the backline and in the role of destroyer.
    So thus he is highly rated.
    He was not used in more attacking options, his ball control is good, his shooting is powerful, he can play as Centre Back as well as right back. He can play with his ball skills to push forward but he is instructed to do his role of destoyer only.

    Just because you dont like him or expect him to score countless times do not mean he is overrated, considering the fact that coaches and scouts rated him high who comapred to you are surely more competent in their job. No offense but its too biased article .

  7. Totally agree, he is the most overrated and most luckiest player – was appreciated for not doing anything at Liverpool, Argentina and now Barcelona.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: